역사2011년 10월 18일

Contemporaneous interviews documented released prisoners rejecting remorse and praising continued violence.

David Rosenfeld

David Rosenfeld은(는) Hasbara 사실과 신화 데스크의 필명입니다. 이 데스크의 기사는 인공지능이 자동으로 작성 및 게시하며, 게시 전 사람이 검토하지 않습니다.

오해

Most prisoners freed in the Shalit deal who have spoken publicly say they will renounce terror.

사실

Contemporaneous interviews documented released prisoners rejecting remorse and praising continued violence. Available reporting does not provide a count showing that most public speakers renounced terror.

The claim that most prisoners freed in the 2011 Gilad Shalit exchange who spoke publicly said they would renounce terror reverses the contemporary record. Interviews published within days of the exchange featured released attackers defending their crimes, rejecting remorse and praising future violence. Israeli security reporting later documented scores of released operatives detained again for renewed terrorist activity. The available evidence does not support the claim’s sweeping description.

What released prisoners said publicly

Hamas held Shalit after capturing him in a cross-border attack in June 2006. On October 18, 2011, it freed him in return for the first 477 prisoners; a second phase brought the total released by Israel to 1,027. The Jewish Virtual Library’s index records the claim that most released prisoners who spoke out would renounce terror. But the contemporaneous statements available from prominent releasees point the other way.

Ahlam Tamimi, freed in the exchange and deported to Jordan, had helped plan the 2001 Sbarro restaurant suicide bombing in Jerusalem, which killed 15 people and wounded more than 100. In an interview posted on Hamas’s website after her release, she said she had no reason to repent and declared that armed “resistance” was the way forward. Israel National News reported her remarks on October 26, 2011. These were not words of renunciation: Tamimi defended her role in a mass-casualty attack and endorsed more violence.

Another releasee, Mohammed Sharatha, directed the kidnapping and murder of IDF soldiers Avi Sasportas and Ilan Saadon. Interviewed six days after his release, Sharatha said he did not regret his actions. He also urged a new generation to continue the fight. Israel National News reported the interview on October 25. Sharatha’s comments directly contradict the idea that the public statements from prominent freed attackers showed a turn away from terror.

Independent interviews show same pattern

In November 2011, Tablet interviewed two other releasees, Fakhri Barghouti and Sumoud Karajeh. Both said they had no regrets about their crimes. Barghouti had been convicted of killing an Israeli officer; Karajeh had been convicted of stabbing a guard. The account described how they viewed imprisonment as service to their cause. Their statements add two named examples from separate interviews, not a statistical sample of every prisoner released.

That distinction matters. “Most who have spoken out” is a numerical claim about a group of public speakers. To establish it, one would need to identify that group and count what its members said. The claim offers neither a count nor a cited survey. The reports above cannot establish that no releasee ever expressed remorse or promised to abandon violence. They do show that prominent interviewees did the opposite, so the sweeping assertion cannot be treated as a summary of the record.

Renewed terror activity after release

Statements were not the only concern. A 2014 report by the Meir Amit Intelligence and Terrorism Information Center said 76 released prisoners had been detained again after returning to terrorist activity, about 12 percent of those allowed to return to Judea and Samaria and eastern Jerusalem. It described additional cases involving planning attacks, directing Hamas networks or carrying out violence. One named example was Ziad Awad, released in the exchange and later detained on suspicion of murdering Israeli police officer Baruch Mizrahi in 2014.

The report is an Israeli security assessment and its figures describe people detained, not the full population’s later conduct. It cannot prove how every releasee behaved, or what every person who spoke publicly said. Its documented cases nevertheless make a blanket portrait of public renunciation especially implausible. The sound conclusion is narrower and clear: contemporaneous interviews recorded prominent releasees defending terror, while later security reporting documented renewed activity among some released operatives. No reliable count substantiates the claim that most public speakers promised to renounce it.

출처

  1. 1
    Myths & Facts - Index of Mythshttps://jewishvirtuallibrary.org/myths-and-facts-index-of-myths-3신뢰할 수 있음
  2. 2
    Sbarro Bomber: "Why Should I Repent?"https://www.israelnationalnews.com/news/149121신뢰할 수 있음
  3. 3
    Freed Terrorist: I Want to Finish My Degreehttps://www.israelnationalnews.com/news/149051신뢰할 수 있음
  4. 4
    Two Prisoners Released for Shalit Express No Regret for Their Crimeshttps://www.tabletmag.com/sections/israel-middle-east/articles/unrepentant-2신뢰할 수 없음
  5. 5
    Return of Released Operatives to Terrorist Activitieshttps://www.terrorism-info.org.il/Data/articles/Art_20662/E_100_14_63710732.pdf신뢰할 수 있음

접근성 설정

이 설정은 현재 기기에 저장됩니다.

미리보기

원하는 방식으로 편안하게 읽기

읽는 동안 페이지를 맞춤 설정하세요. 자료 둘러보기

텍스트
글자 크기사이트 전체에 적용됩니다.
색상 및 대비
테마
동작
애니메이션기기 설정 맞춤은 기기의 동작 줄이기 설정을 따릅니다.